💹ISOs Decoded: Turning Incentive Stock Options Into a Wealth Building Superpower

☕ Good morning SenseMakers!

Last week we focused on RSUs and the smart use of 10b51 plans to turn forced income into deliberate diversification. If you missed it, you can read that edition here and see how the right rules based plan keeps you out of trouble and on track.

This week we are zooming in on Incentive Stock Options. Managed well, ISOs can be one of the most tax efficient wealth tools available. Managed casually, they can create surprise tax bills and force you into reactive decisions.

Let’s turn ISOs from confusing to clear.

🎯 What makes ISOs different

ISOs give you the right to buy company stock at a preset strike price. If you meet two holding period rules, your profit can qualify for long term capital gains tax instead of ordinary income tax. 

You must hold the shares for at least one year after you exercise, and you must also hold for at least two years from the original grant date.

For high earners, the difference between ordinary rates and long term capital gains is real money. That is why ISOs are so valuable.

A lesser known rule matters too. The ISO one hundred thousand rule limits the amount that can first become exercisable in a single calendar year, measured by grant date fair market value. 

Amounts over that limit are treated like NSOs. This does not kill the value of your options, it simply changes the tax treatment on the excess.

⚠️ The AMT trap, and how to stay out of it

The Alternative Minimum Tax is the silent risk in many ISO plans. When you exercise, the bargain element, the spread between market value and strike, is added to your AMT calculation even if you do not sell any shares. That can create a large tax bill on paper gains.

Quick example: You exercise five thousand ISOs at ten dollars when the stock trades at fifty dollars. The forty dollar spread creates two hundred thousand dollars of AMT income. If you did not model this in advance, you may find an unpleasant surprise at tax time.

How to manage it. Exercise in smaller chunks over several years to keep AMT within guardrails. Target lower income years such as a sabbatical, a move to a new role, or partial retirement.

Run AMT forecasts with your advisor before you click exercise. Remember the AMT credit. If AMT hits this year, you may be able to claim a credit in future years when your regular tax is higher than your AMT.

⏳ Timing is everything

With ISOs, price gets the attention, but timing does the heavy lifting.

If you have a big bonus or promotion coming up, consider waiting to exercise.

If an income dip is on the horizon, that can be the moment to exercise and start your long term clock.

If you are leaving the company, know your timelines. To keep ISO status, many plans require exercise within ninety days of separation. After that window, remaining options often convert to NSOs.

Early exercise and the 83b election:

Some plans allow early exercise of unvested ISOs. If allowed, and if you file an 83b election within thirty days, you choose to recognize income when the value is low, and you start the long term capital gains clock earlier.

This move can reduce future tax, but it carries risk because you are paying tax before the shares fully vest. Use it when valuation is modest, liquidity is planned, and you have clear confidence in the role and the company.

🧭 Qualifying vs disqualifying dispositions

To keep ISO tax treatment you need a qualifying disposition. That is the one year after exercise and two years after grant rule. Sell too soon and you have a disqualifying disposition.

What happens if you sell early:

1. Part of your gain is taxed as ordinary income, generally up to the bargain element at exercise

2. Any additional gain is capital gain, short term or long term depending on your holding period after exercise

3. The upside is that a same day sale can avoid AMT altogether, so in some cases a planned disqualifying disposition is the better economic choice

This is why modeling matters. Sometimes you intentionally disqualify because the cash flow and AMT outcomes are better.

🏗️ Two client stories, two different outcomes

Story one, the slow and steady plan

An executive came to us with $500K in vested ISOs and a stomach full of anxiety. They had done nothing for two years because AMT felt like a black box. Together we built a phased plan. 

We set an AMT ceiling for the year, then staged four exercises tied to quarterly windows. We paired those exercises with charitable gifting and loss harvesting to offset tax where possible. 

Over eighteen months they reduced company stock to fifteen percent of net worth, funded a new diversified portfolio, and used some proceeds to purchase a vacation home they had been eyeing for years. They did not chase price, they followed a plan that respected tax, risk, and life goals.

Story two, the quick pivot

Another leader faced a different challenge. The company entered a volatile period, and they were considering a cashless exercise to lock in gains. 

A quick model showed that a same day sale would be a disqualifying disposition, but it would also avoid AMT and free cash to cover a down payment on a new home and build an emergency reserve. 

We green lit a staged cashless exercise over two trading windows. The outcome was lower complexity, no AMT, and a cleaner balance sheet. Sometimes the right answer is not the purest tax answer, it is the plan that fits the household.

🧰 Practical ISO moves you can use

✅ Map your ISO calendar. Know grant dates, vest dates, expiration, and separation rules

✅ Decide on your concentration ceiling. Many executives cap any single stock at ten to twenty percent of net worth

✅ Use a tax projection tool. Model exercise sizes across several years to keep AMT manageable

✅Consider charitable gifting of appreciated stock after a qualifying disposition to reduce future tax

✅Coordinate with prior RSU planning. Last week we covered how 10b51 can automate RSU sales. You can use similar rules based thinking to schedule ISO exercises, even if the mechanics differ.

🎥 Want the full breakdown in seven minutes

I recorded a short video that covers ISOs, RSUs, ESPPs, NSOs, performance shares, and smart ways to integrate equity into your larger plan. It also includes a quick note on early exercise and the 83b election.

Watch the video here:

💡 Making sense of ISOs

Here is the bottom line.

💸 ISOs can convert effort into long term wealth when you respect the holding periods and plan your timing 

💸 AMT is real, but it is manageable with phased exercises and smart scheduling

💸Sometimes a planned disqualifying disposition is the right move, especially when cash flow or risk reduction is the priority

💸Diversification is not optional. Use gains to build the rest of your life plan, not just a larger single stock position

If you want help building a personal exercise map that integrates tax, cash flow, and your life goals, reach out and we will build it together.

As always, I hope this helps you to Prioritize Your Version of a Rich Life.

Until next week!

This information is not intended to be a substitute for specific individualized tax advice. We suggest that you discuss your specific tax issues with a qualified tax advisor.

Security and Advisory Services offered through LPL Financial, a registered investment advisor. Member FINRA/SIPC The information contained in this e-mail message is being transmitted to and is intended for the use of only the individual(s) to whom it is addressed. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, you are hereby advised that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this message in error, please immediately delete.